As more people get vaccinated, fears about the COVID-19 vaccines are reaching all-time lows. According to our latest Verywell Health Vaccine Sentiment Tracker, only 13% of our surveyed audience would definitely not agree to take a free COVID-19 shot. This is the lowest rejector number we’ve seen since starting the survey in December.
But as a return to pre-pandemic life seems imminent, Americans are on the fence about something new: vaccine passports. Everyone who gets vaccinated receives a vaccine card, but those are easily forged and may be lost or destroyed accidentally.
Vaccine passports would likely digitize this information. Currently, multiple private sector companies are developing digital systems to collect and verify personal COVID-19 vaccine status and potentially also testing information. The idea is this would live in a digital app the user can present when boarding an airplane or entering a restaurant for indoor dining. But for those without access to smartphones, it could also be a written certificate.
According to our survey:
55% of Americans think that people should have to prove they’ve been vaccinated28% of Americans reject the idea of having to prove vaccination status17% of Americans are unsure how they feel about it
Why Are People Divided on Vaccine Passports?
While the support for vaccine passports varies by the situation, survey respondents who support vaccine verification are more likely to be vaccinated themselves. They identify more often as Democrats, millennials, and men. Gen Z (people between the ages of 18 and 24) appear more against the idea, which aligns with our previous findings showing that they also tend to be more hesitant toward the COVID-19 vaccines in general.
Acceptors: Those who would agree to be vaccinatedRejectors: Those who would not agree to take a vaccineUndecideds: Those who don’t know if they would take a vaccineVaccinated: Those who have received a COVID-19 vaccination
Based on statements from the Biden administration, there won’t be a federal vaccination verification system or vaccine mandate in our future. However, the U.S. will issue some form of guidance for states and public companies looking to implement a vaccine passport system.
Some states are coming out strong against their implementation. Arizona’s governor signed an executive order barring local governments from making “vaccine passports” a requirement for people to enter businesses or get services. Florida and Texas did the same, and Tennessee’s governor is supporting legislation against it.
On the other hand, there are states who are already working to implement a version of verification, like New York and Hawaii. Many universities are also requiring proof of vaccination.
Hesitancy toward vaccine passports may also stem from ethical considerations. Requiring proof of vaccination can further place people who don’t have easy access to technology like smartphones at a disadvantage, as many vaccine passports are built around digital apps. It can also potentially punish people who may not yet have easy access to the vaccines or who are wary of the U.S. health system.
Vaccine Verification Attitudes Depend on the Situation
In our survey, approval for vaccine verification varied by scenario. According to our data, people are more comfortable with the idea of verification if there’s a precedent for this type of documentation in the space, like:
International travelSchoolsConcerts or sporting eventOffices or workplacesDomestic travel
For many respondents, vaccine verification makes sense for air travel or international travel—65% were in favor of vaccine verification to travel abroad. These situations already required health and safety protocols over the past year, like a quarantine period or negative COVID test result.
About half of respondents support vaccine verification for sporting or live music events. Many concert companies and sporting venues are already implementing vaccine verification. Ticketmaster will be checking vaccine status for concerts.
Vaccine Verification Is Not a New Concept
Proof of vaccination is already required in many instances throughout the world. For example, travel to some areas where the Yellow Fever virus is present requires proof of vaccination called International Certificate of Vaccination or Prophylaxis (ICVP or the “yellow card”).
Schools and workplaces have also historically required certain vaccinations, like tetanus and chickenpox shots. In our survey, 65% of parents favor a vaccine verification system. In many states, teachers were given early priority for vaccination to encourage safely getting back to in-person teaching.
As we approach herd immunity (somewhere in the range of 70-80% of the population fully vaccinated), these questions will be become less pressing. But for now, vaccine passports will be a patchwork of different systems and policies throughout the U.S.
The information in this article is current as of the date listed, which means newer information may be available when you read this. For the most recent updates on COVID-19, visit our coronavirus news page.
